Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sandra Pinches's avatar

Dr. Li, thank you so much for composing and sharing this article!

I am a clinical psychologist, and I work with adolescents and adults. I live in Oregon, and I have recently decided to stop seeing adolescents in my practice, because healthcare professionals here are at risk legally if they refuse to work within the "gender affirmative care" model. It isn't possible to screen gender-confused children out of my practice, because an increasing number of young women that I am seeing for other reasons will suddenly announce to me that they are "non-binary," without having reported any previous history of gender confusion. It is completely obvious that cutting off their breasts is not the proper way to address their psychological problems, and I never dreamed that this ancient form of torture would be reinstated as a psychiatric approach within pediatric medicine or my profession.

More generally, I feel intense grief and rage about the destruction of my beloved profession by doctoral level psychologists who apparently have no clue what science or clinical practice even are, much less how to employ these methodologies. It is difficult to understand how people who must be at least of average intelligence and who attended what used to be the "best schools in the country" ended up so ignorant and brutish in their thinking and their behavior.

Looking from the outside at the woke cult and its obsession with "trans identities," I see lots of symptoms of personality disorders being acted out en masse. Not only do many of the leaders of this movement behave in a highly narcissistic or sociopathic manner, the cult as a whole also does. Many observers have described the woke cult as a social pathology, e.g. Elon Musk's characterization of the cult as "a mind virus," and I agree that it is a mass mental illness rather than a "political" movement.

I hope that pediatricians will listen to you and will take time to actually inform themselves about the appallingly destructive mistreatment of children that is being perpetrated by trans activist healthcare professionals. Vulnerable young people are being harmed by "gender affirmative care" whether or not they know it now or ever during their lives. When the adults who are charged with protecting children abuse them instead, abuse becomes normal to those kids, and in many cases they never recognize how horribly they were betrayed.

Expand full comment
Eric Coppala's avatar

A powerful read. I’m reading Time to Think currently. I’m not a physician nor do I work in mental health or with children. Having 2 older teens, 1 of which told us 3 years ago she was trans and wanted an elective mastectomy, I’m very concerned with professional groups legitimizing this new insanity. By the grace of God, our daughter has moved way from the trans obsession and moved more center. After reading some of Hannah Barnes’ work, I see similarities in what our daughter struggled with. She began following influencers on social and became mesmerized by the promises of a rebirth in transitioning. I empathize with any parent and child struggling with identity and am thankful for voices of reason pulling the pendulum back.

Expand full comment
86 more comments...

No posts