Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michael McQuate's avatar

As soon as I heard this interview on NPR I wrote an email to Dr. Vilain. This is the last line of the the email I sent...Your parting advice was that instead of focusing on the actual, real issues of unfairness is that we should be “celebrating diversity” instead. I'd invite you to stand at the finish line of a race where some “assigned female at birth” girl just got smoked by someone who is physically and in every other way a male, and as they see their podium possibilities and maybe even their chance at a college scholarship evaporating, tell them they should be focused on “celebrating diversity”.

Expand full comment
Dave's avatar

How about if we find a way to tie the number of trans women competing in women's sports to the number of trans men competing in men's sports? So long as those numbers are equal, I'm ok with transgender people competing in the category with which they identify. But of course we all know this won't be the case.

Indeed, all discussion seems to take place around trans women competing as women, and not trans men competing as men. Implicit here is the mutual understanding, even among the Dr. Vilain types, that trans men will not be able to compete with men at any high level in most sports. Because... biology. It's a real thing, no matter how much woke "scientists" try to spin it.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts