Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Holly MathNerd's avatar

There's a lot here, and at least some of it seems to be tied to a beef with a (former) friend of yours, so I'll just lay out some objections to the idea that Wokism isn't filling a god-hole. (BTW, I'm an atheist, but a reluctant one--I wish there was a benevolent father figure looking out for at least some of us. I'd love to believe that. There just isn't.) Since October 7, we've watched Westerners demonstrate that they are suicidally committed to something (Queers for Palestine marching for people who explicitly tell them that they'd love to toss them off the nearest building; young women chanting "They've got tanks; *we've* got hang-gliders" about rapist-murderers). Wokism has original sin in varying degrees by identity caste except black or brown women, preferably ones born male or engaged in sex work. Unlike Christianity, however, there is no redemption from the original sin. What word would we give to a belief system so all-consuming that it can cause people to believe in original sin and take positions as dramatically opposed to their self-interest that it might as well be "Chickens for KFC" or "Mice for Outlawing the Spaying and Neutering of Cats"? If not religion....what, exactly, do we call that? Some would call it a lack of reason, but these people universally believe that theirs is the reasonable position, which is why Colin, the owner of this Substack, literally cannot get a job at a university because he believes in biology. If this isn't a religion, it's something so like one that saying it's not a religion seems like a distinction without a difference.

Expand full comment
Sandra Pinches's avatar

Thank you for this response to Ayaan Hirsi Ali's recent article regarding her conversion to Christianity. I will start by saying that, like Ayaan, I would love to be able to be a part of a spiritual community, but I have never been able to squeeze myself into the thought prisons that organized religions generally become. The same is true with respect to political parties.

I do not have the privilege of knowing Ayaan and I do not want to criticize her choice of religion. What struck me most about her article is its similarity to other recently published accounts of conversions of former "Progressive Democrats" to GOP or "conservative" affiliation. (Sasha Stone, for example).

I can appreciate the felt need to belong to something bigger than oneself, an intellectual and emotional "home" that includes the perceived power of numbers and longevity to oppose woke tyranny. There is a lot of felt tension for many of us in not being able to enter such a home. Yet all of these systems have tended to develop the same authoritarianism and internal pressure towards conformity that repels individuals like me. Those tendencies appear to not be accidental, but rather are essential elements of what appeals to so many members of religious and political organizations.

As our society continues to disintegrate, we are seeing more attempts at self-conversion to thought constructs that offer a promise of being safe harbors from the vulnerabilities of uncertainty, isolation and attack by outsiders. I kind of envy those who can pull off this kind of conversion, but adopting the beliefs of Old Time Religion is not the answer for me.

Expand full comment
45 more comments...

No posts