Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sufeitzy's avatar

Would that a supernatural museum could exist, no building would be large enough to hold the Bazillion fantasies, the haunted museum wing, the Babylonian mythology wing, the Japanese demons wing... the Catholic Church wing... and which version of each superstition.

Agreed that superstition (“faith-based”) beliefs have no place in a science museum, there are plenty churches, temples, sacred spaces which are precisely museums of superstition.

Expand full comment
PAUL NATHANSON's avatar

The essay, an excellent one, ends as follows: "Carl Sagan wrote a book promoting science, skepticism, and critical thinking titled “The Demon-Haunted World.” Museum staff might benefit from reading this book, recognizing that the “demons” mentioned in the title can’t be summoned with a whistle. Because they’re not real."

This sets up an unnecessary conflict and therefore contributes to the notion that religion is the enemy of science, which is not necessarily true. I think that a better concluding line would be this: "Because this is a museum of science, not religion, and therefore has nothing to say about the whistle's religious efficacy."

Expand full comment
117 more comments...

No posts