The NYT article contains this highly misleading 4th paragraph:
>If and when teenagers should be allowed to undergo transgender treatments and surgeries has become a raging debate within the political world. Opponents say teenagers are too young to make such decisions, but supporters including an array of medical experts posit that young people with gender dysphoria face depression and worsening distress if their issues go unaddressed.
Note that only supporters of medical treatments are said to have "an array of medical experts" on their side, opponents are portraryed as "political".
As an NYT subscriber, I wrote the author of the article a polite email pointing out that there is "an array of medical experts" on the other side as well, which the author knows perfectly well.
I also said in the email that I'm sure the author is under tremendous pressure from trans activists (likely including friends and colleagues) to tilt the reporting, and that I hope the pressure can be resisted in the interests of fairly presenting the facts.
Lobotomies once had an array of supporters, including the Nobel Prize awarding committee.
There is no such thing as gender dysphoria. The feeling that one's body is wrong is a symptom of a deeper condition, not a reality or condition by itself. In males, it's usually autogynephilia or porn addiction. In females, it's usually childhood sexual abuse trauma.
Allowing this for adults means children will be targeted. There is no stopping it. It all must be ended, for all ages. It's simply based on a lie.
It's more common that it's autogynephilia or porn addiction in males because males are driven by perversion. A minority may have abuse, like someone like Walt Heyer.
But for females, it's more common that it's sexual abuse. They're trying to become the threat that abused them as a way to self-protect. The problem is, that is impossible.
Inflammation may also be involved. Lenz et al. triggered allergies in pregnant dams and the offspring became LGBT. Women with PCOS (of inflammatory nature) have high testosterone, high LGBT rates. Obese men have disturbed sexual hormones etc. Bipolars have brain inflammation and high rates of bisexuality. Dr. Will Powers has noticed a high rate of inflammatory disorders in the trans community and a subgroup that can't increase cortisol when needed. The brain-adrenal-thyroid-gonads axis is involved.
Sorry but that's as unhelpful as saying that sex is a spectrum. It's equally but oppositely wrong. We should not counter 'their' stupidity with an equivalent stupidity in the other direction. Of course gender dysphoria is real. And yes, there will almost always be some deeper reason for it but that doesn't mean that the plain observed reality of gender dysphoria isn't there, it means, as you say, that we usually need to dig deeper to treat it.
Sex is binary and immutable--female and male, nothing more. A chromosome test proves it, egg and sperm proves it, and genetic disorders do not mean that it's not binary.
If you're going to use a stupid term like "gender dysphoria," then you should be able to define "gender."
Nope. 'gender dysphoria' is a single semantic entity that can't properly be dismantled. We both know what it means -- people who are unhappy with the reality of their biological sex. We also both know that the word 'gender' by itself is an ideological battleground and different tribes will give different definitions. BTW don't be hostile, we're on the same side of the barricade, I just think your strategy on this point is not helpful to our side.
I noticed the article didn't mention the Cass Report or the official legal actions by European authorities restricting the use of puberty blockers and hormones. I guess the Borg's news blackout on those developments remains in full force and effect.
This is criminal. Being complicit with WPATH and hiding medical reviews? This is so abhorrent I’m questioning whether I read the article correctly. Good fracking grief! The insanity is incredible. And yes, of course the White House with its rainbow colored display, announcing a trans holiday on the same day as Easter is complicit. Parents losing their parental rights to protect their children from being butchered. It’s all so outrageous! But then I’m not just old school, I’m old, old, old school.
Apparently the American Academy of Pediatrics, a formerly respected institution, has also been complicit—you mention it elsewhere (in the Free Press), just wanted to highlight it as it is what my first daughter’s pediatrician had tried to gaslight me with and that is COMPLETELY maddening as they purport to be an authority to your kids (and then that triangulates YOU as the mom and dad out of the picture). Then, society is perplexed as to why this Academy with all its lofty goals of guiding children and parents could do so much harm 🤬. I want to be the friend to have drinks with you and do talk about The Issue. Gah! 😵💫
I'd like to think that this scandal is a sign the horror of gender affirming care is ending, but as Helen Joyce pointed out, the parents who have transitioned their children (and I'd argue the doctors performing the surgeries) are going to be unable to accept the depravity of what they've done for their own sanity. They're going to dig in for the rest of their lives like the WW2 Japanese soldiers stranded in the south Pacific in denial that the war has ended, was lost.
I’m a bit surprised JH didn’t publish. They are well within their rights to, to whichever papers they want. It’s often considered bad practice to publish without the consent of all authors, but it’s not illegal to. Perhaps they will change their mind with time when the needle on this issuw shifts.
Ah! That is disappointing. Usually academics that I have worked with (I’m employed in a private corporation) fight hard to maintain the IP as the publishing is of much greater to the researchers that it is to the corporation. But in this case I could see how that may differ.
This is different, they were reviewing existing studies, not conducting a new one. It's more like reviewing proposals or being on a panel of experts to write a report on something for some government agency. Those things don't necessarily get published, they go to the commissioning agency, which decides whether to release them or not.
I have no experience with this issue, but I do wonder whether JHU medical institutions would do the same thing with drug research by faculty that came to similar adverse conclusions regarding the subject drug.
JHU used to be a beacon of sanity in this field, but the Christian psychiatrist who was head of the department retired and Dr. Richard/Rachel Levine must have been given a role in selecting his replacement.
Richard Levine was confirmed in order to do this. This is the goal, and it always has been.
If this is allowed for adults, children will be targeted. There is no stopping it. That is why the whole thing must be stopped. It is a fraud, for everyone, at any age.
Children can no more "consent" to have their healthy breasts and genitalia removed or take puberty blockers than they can
"consent" to have sex with an adult.
Similarly, parents and doctors can no more approve such permanent mutilation simply because a minor child desires it than they can approve their participation in pedophilia.
Ultimately society will see the truth and ban the practice as we have banned female genital mutilation. Do people support that practice if the parents consent? I truly hope not
It is monstrous to believe otherwise and those who do will ultimately be held to account for their actions. The obscene bureaucrat Rachel (Richard) Levine among those in the dock.
Really appreciating your work. As a philosopher I’ve been trying to make sense of this weird cultural shift from a conceptual rather than from a medical angle. Some pieces are probably user-unfriendly but the concluding piece conveys the gist if anyone’s interested! https://neilgascoigne.substack.com/p/terf-love?r=3h9xp4
These truths need to get out to the wider public. People need to see that we cannot trust the authorities. We are private citizens, they are public servants. They are here to serve us and keep us safe, they are lying to us and conspiring against us and not acting in our best interest. People need to see this.
It's interesting to me me that WPATH wanted Hopkins to conduct the review in the first place...it suggest overconfidence that Hopkins would legitimately affirim WPATH's standards and/or confidence that they could exert sufficient pressure.
I was asked by a large blue state Medicaid program to do my usual policy review and analysis and make a recommendation when Obama told govt insurance programs to pay for “gender services.” I realized after looking up all the WPATH “experts” they were a sham. Group of LGBTQ activists who’d done no actual research. But of course, the Obama WH pointed to them as “experts.” 🙄 The best research available were two longitudinal registry studies from Sweden and either Denmark or the Netherlands. The suicide rates in late 20s went back up. The worst thing was the clear ten-year early mortality for those who did full transitions. I told the state not to cover them, it’s all cosmetic, but they had no choice. The eye opener was the first request for a patient estimated $500K MINIMUM up to a MILLION if all the surgeries done! Knew right then this was about the MONEY. 😡
This is an obvious attempt to discredit WPATH. Anyone who reads what they produce in good faith will find a highly professional organization that produces fact-based, science-based opinions. Read their work for yourself and form your own opinion. Don’t listen to people with an obvious agenda like this to give you the whole story.
I wonder what the underlying motivator is. Is the Democratic party or the AAP taking huge donations from pharmaceutal companies or medical insurance companies? There is a large amount of hidden investment somewhere.
The NYT article contains this highly misleading 4th paragraph:
>If and when teenagers should be allowed to undergo transgender treatments and surgeries has become a raging debate within the political world. Opponents say teenagers are too young to make such decisions, but supporters including an array of medical experts posit that young people with gender dysphoria face depression and worsening distress if their issues go unaddressed.
Note that only supporters of medical treatments are said to have "an array of medical experts" on their side, opponents are portraryed as "political".
As an NYT subscriber, I wrote the author of the article a polite email pointing out that there is "an array of medical experts" on the other side as well, which the author knows perfectly well.
I also said in the email that I'm sure the author is under tremendous pressure from trans activists (likely including friends and colleagues) to tilt the reporting, and that I hope the pressure can be resisted in the interests of fairly presenting the facts.
Lobotomies once had an array of supporters, including the Nobel Prize awarding committee.
There is no such thing as gender dysphoria. The feeling that one's body is wrong is a symptom of a deeper condition, not a reality or condition by itself. In males, it's usually autogynephilia or porn addiction. In females, it's usually childhood sexual abuse trauma.
Allowing this for adults means children will be targeted. There is no stopping it. It all must be ended, for all ages. It's simply based on a lie.
In males, it's usually childhood sexual abuse trauma.
It's more common that it's autogynephilia or porn addiction in males because males are driven by perversion. A minority may have abuse, like someone like Walt Heyer.
But for females, it's more common that it's sexual abuse. They're trying to become the threat that abused them as a way to self-protect. The problem is, that is impossible.
Inflammation may also be involved. Lenz et al. triggered allergies in pregnant dams and the offspring became LGBT. Women with PCOS (of inflammatory nature) have high testosterone, high LGBT rates. Obese men have disturbed sexual hormones etc. Bipolars have brain inflammation and high rates of bisexuality. Dr. Will Powers has noticed a high rate of inflammatory disorders in the trans community and a subgroup that can't increase cortisol when needed. The brain-adrenal-thyroid-gonads axis is involved.
Males are driven by perversion? Sure, and females are driven by fashion and popularity contests. That accounts for ROGD just fine.
> There is no such thing as gender dysphoria.
Sorry but that's as unhelpful as saying that sex is a spectrum. It's equally but oppositely wrong. We should not counter 'their' stupidity with an equivalent stupidity in the other direction. Of course gender dysphoria is real. And yes, there will almost always be some deeper reason for it but that doesn't mean that the plain observed reality of gender dysphoria isn't there, it means, as you say, that we usually need to dig deeper to treat it.
Bulllshit, Ray.
And I'll prove it.
Sex is binary and immutable--female and male, nothing more. A chromosome test proves it, egg and sperm proves it, and genetic disorders do not mean that it's not binary.
If you're going to use a stupid term like "gender dysphoria," then you should be able to define "gender."
Go ahead. What is "gender"? Define it.
Nope. 'gender dysphoria' is a single semantic entity that can't properly be dismantled. We both know what it means -- people who are unhappy with the reality of their biological sex. We also both know that the word 'gender' by itself is an ideological battleground and different tribes will give different definitions. BTW don't be hostile, we're on the same side of the barricade, I just think your strategy on this point is not helpful to our side.
I noticed the article didn't mention the Cass Report or the official legal actions by European authorities restricting the use of puberty blockers and hormones. I guess the Borg's news blackout on those developments remains in full force and effect.
How ironic that the author implies medical evidentiary support when said evidence is distributed by WPATH, the group at the heart of the scandal.
This is criminal. Being complicit with WPATH and hiding medical reviews? This is so abhorrent I’m questioning whether I read the article correctly. Good fracking grief! The insanity is incredible. And yes, of course the White House with its rainbow colored display, announcing a trans holiday on the same day as Easter is complicit. Parents losing their parental rights to protect their children from being butchered. It’s all so outrageous! But then I’m not just old school, I’m old, old, old school.
Apparently the American Academy of Pediatrics, a formerly respected institution, has also been complicit—you mention it elsewhere (in the Free Press), just wanted to highlight it as it is what my first daughter’s pediatrician had tried to gaslight me with and that is COMPLETELY maddening as they purport to be an authority to your kids (and then that triangulates YOU as the mom and dad out of the picture). Then, society is perplexed as to why this Academy with all its lofty goals of guiding children and parents could do so much harm 🤬. I want to be the friend to have drinks with you and do talk about The Issue. Gah! 😵💫
I'd like to think that this scandal is a sign the horror of gender affirming care is ending, but as Helen Joyce pointed out, the parents who have transitioned their children (and I'd argue the doctors performing the surgeries) are going to be unable to accept the depravity of what they've done for their own sanity. They're going to dig in for the rest of their lives like the WW2 Japanese soldiers stranded in the south Pacific in denial that the war has ended, was lost.
I’m a bit surprised JH didn’t publish. They are well within their rights to, to whichever papers they want. It’s often considered bad practice to publish without the consent of all authors, but it’s not illegal to. Perhaps they will change their mind with time when the needle on this issuw shifts.
My guess is that JHU was paid by WPATH to do this, under contract, and so the IP belongs to WPATH.
Ah! That is disappointing. Usually academics that I have worked with (I’m employed in a private corporation) fight hard to maintain the IP as the publishing is of much greater to the researchers that it is to the corporation. But in this case I could see how that may differ.
This is different, they were reviewing existing studies, not conducting a new one. It's more like reviewing proposals or being on a panel of experts to write a report on something for some government agency. Those things don't necessarily get published, they go to the commissioning agency, which decides whether to release them or not.
Fair enough, thanks for explaining.
I have no experience with this issue, but I do wonder whether JHU medical institutions would do the same thing with drug research by faculty that came to similar adverse conclusions regarding the subject drug.
JHU used to be a beacon of sanity in this field, but the Christian psychiatrist who was head of the department retired and Dr. Richard/Rachel Levine must have been given a role in selecting his replacement.
Richard Levine was confirmed in order to do this. This is the goal, and it always has been.
If this is allowed for adults, children will be targeted. There is no stopping it. That is why the whole thing must be stopped. It is a fraud, for everyone, at any age.
https://kathighsmith.substack.com/p/a-political-troon-the-ridiculous
Children can no more "consent" to have their healthy breasts and genitalia removed or take puberty blockers than they can
"consent" to have sex with an adult.
Similarly, parents and doctors can no more approve such permanent mutilation simply because a minor child desires it than they can approve their participation in pedophilia.
Ultimately society will see the truth and ban the practice as we have banned female genital mutilation. Do people support that practice if the parents consent? I truly hope not
It is monstrous to believe otherwise and those who do will ultimately be held to account for their actions. The obscene bureaucrat Rachel (Richard) Levine among those in the dock.
Let’s see what news agencies cover this.
The Economist:
https://www.economist.com/united-states/2024/06/27/research-into-trans-medicine-has-been-manipulated
Really appreciating your work. As a philosopher I’ve been trying to make sense of this weird cultural shift from a conceptual rather than from a medical angle. Some pieces are probably user-unfriendly but the concluding piece conveys the gist if anyone’s interested! https://neilgascoigne.substack.com/p/terf-love?r=3h9xp4
These truths need to get out to the wider public. People need to see that we cannot trust the authorities. We are private citizens, they are public servants. They are here to serve us and keep us safe, they are lying to us and conspiring against us and not acting in our best interest. People need to see this.
https://open.substack.com/pub/caroldansereau/p/affirming-trans-identities-is-harmful?r=505il&utm_medium=ios
Who gave WPATH all the power? WTF?!
It's interesting to me me that WPATH wanted Hopkins to conduct the review in the first place...it suggest overconfidence that Hopkins would legitimately affirim WPATH's standards and/or confidence that they could exert sufficient pressure.
I was asked by a large blue state Medicaid program to do my usual policy review and analysis and make a recommendation when Obama told govt insurance programs to pay for “gender services.” I realized after looking up all the WPATH “experts” they were a sham. Group of LGBTQ activists who’d done no actual research. But of course, the Obama WH pointed to them as “experts.” 🙄 The best research available were two longitudinal registry studies from Sweden and either Denmark or the Netherlands. The suicide rates in late 20s went back up. The worst thing was the clear ten-year early mortality for those who did full transitions. I told the state not to cover them, it’s all cosmetic, but they had no choice. The eye opener was the first request for a patient estimated $500K MINIMUM up to a MILLION if all the surgeries done! Knew right then this was about the MONEY. 😡
This is an obvious attempt to discredit WPATH. Anyone who reads what they produce in good faith will find a highly professional organization that produces fact-based, science-based opinions. Read their work for yourself and form your own opinion. Don’t listen to people with an obvious agenda like this to give you the whole story.
I wonder what the underlying motivator is. Is the Democratic party or the AAP taking huge donations from pharmaceutal companies or medical insurance companies? There is a large amount of hidden investment somewhere.
I know this was a long time ago but I would put money down this is connnected to the Pritzkers.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jennifer_Pritzker
He is a billionaire TIM who is politically connected and a huge dem donor.