Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Puzzle Therapy's avatar

So almost three-fourths of adolescent girls will desist within five years under the conditions in which concretizing (official gender marker change) and permanent (medicalization) interventions are rare for minors - the "rare" conditions that both activists and more mainstream supporters of "trans youth" use to justify their positions. That is a huge number that tells a very clear story about what should be evidence based practice for this population. Can the AAP and APA at least take the baby step of acknowledging there is something different about this population that requires a different approach and different recommendations? They can stay out of the political and culture war muck and call it something other than ROGD or social contagion. Just please look at the data and consider that these girls need a different approach.

Then maybe we can get them to start thinking about the implications for other groups of youth and how their ability to predict outcomes is no better than a coin toss.

Expand full comment
JRCCreasey's avatar

Excellent article and vital lines of study and discussion-many more people are affected by this movement than only the subject individuals. I am a grandfather of a now 20 year old man who began his incidious “transition” five years ago (coincidentally he also dropped out of school almost simultaneously). This is definitely heavily influenced by “woke” educational experiences in the public education system. It is ABHORRENT

Expand full comment
26 more comments...

No posts